Thanks for writing this up! I think this proposal sounds pretty reasonable and it avoids one of the issues with capability-based gates that I thought would make such agreements not possible (by saying you can just use whatever interp and monitoring to pass the gate and thus making it a dynamic threshold). I tentatively would be in favor of it over no monitorability commitment at all.
However, I think this proposal does not address what I see as the strongest arguments against an outcome-based commitment ("achieve sufficient monitorability") and in favor of ... (read more)
Thanks for writing this up! I think this proposal sounds pretty reasonable and it avoids one of the issues with capability-based gates that I thought would make such agreements not possible (by saying you can just use whatever interp and monitoring to pass the gate and thus making it a dynamic threshold). I tentatively would be in favor of it over no monitorability commitment at all.
However, I think this proposal does not address what I see as the strongest arguments against an outcome-based commitment ("achieve sufficient monitorability") and in favor of ... (read more)