Recontextualization distills good behavior into a context which allows bad behavior. More specifically, recontextualization is a modification to RL which generates completions from prompts that discourage misbehavior, appends those completions to prompts that are more tolerant of misbehavior, and finally reinforces the model on the recontextualized instruction-completion data. Due to...
Summary: Perfectly labeled outcomes in training can still boost reward hacking tendencies in generalization. This can hold even when the train/test sets are drawn from the exact same distribution. We induce this surprising effect via a form of context distillation, which we call re-contextualization: 1. Generate model completions with a...
Recontextualization distills good behavior into a context which allows bad behavior. More specifically, recontextualization is a modification to RL which generates completions from prompts that discourage misbehavior, appends those completions to prompts that are more tolerant of misbehavior, and finally reinforces the model on the recontextualized instruction-completion data. Due to the data generation and training prompts differing in their attitude towards misbehavior, recontextualization builds resistance to misbehaviors that the training signal mistakenly reinforces.
For example, suppose our reward signal does not robustly penalize deception. Recontextualization generates completions while discouraging deception and then creates training data by updating those completions' prompts to encourage deception. That simple tweak can prevent the model from becoming dishonest!
Read... (read 3013 more words →)
Summary: Perfectly labeled outcomes in training can still boost reward hacking tendencies in generalization. This can hold even when the train/test sets are drawn from the exact same distribution. We induce this surprising effect via a form of context distillation, which we call re-contextualization:
While we solely reinforce honest outcomes, the reasoning traces focus on hacking more than usual. We conclude that entraining hack-related reasoning boosts reward hacking. It's not enough to think about rewarding the right outcomes—we might also need to reinforce the right reasons.
It's often... (read 1143 more words →)
