AI ALIGNMENT FORUM
AF

610
Wikitags
You are viewing version 1.0.0 of this page. Click here to view the latest version.

Coherent Extrapolated Volition

Edited by pedrochaves, radical_negative_one, et al. last updated 13th Feb 2025
You are viewing revision 1.0.0, last edited by Gyrodiot

In developing aligned AI, one acting for our best interests, we would have to take care that it would have implemented, from the beginning, a coherent extrapolated volition of humankind. In calculating CEV, an AI would predict what an idealized version of us would want, "if we knew more, thought faster, were more the people we wished we were, had grown up farther together". It would recursively iterate this prediction for humanity as a whole, and determine the desires which converge. This initial dynamic would be used to generate the AI's utility function.

The main problems with CEV include, firstly, the great difficulty of implementing such a program - “If one attempted to write an ordinary computer program using ordinary computer programming skills, the task would be a thousand lightyears beyond hopeless.” Secondly, the possibility that human values may not converge. Yudkowsky considered CEV obsolete almost immediately after its publication in 2004. He states that there's a "principled distinction between discussing CEV as an initial dynamic of Friendliness, and discussing CEV as a Nice Place to Live" and his essay was essentially conflating the two definitions.

(copied from Coherent Extrapolated Volition)

Subscribe
Discussion
2
Subscribe
Discussion
2
Posts tagged Coherent Extrapolated Volition
49The self-unalignment problem
Jan_Kulveit, rosehadshar
3y
8
16Requirements for a Basin of Attraction to Alignment
RogerDearnaley
2y
0
6Concept extrapolation: key posts
Stuart_Armstrong
4y
0
25Coherent extrapolated dreaming
Alex Flint
3y
5
11How Would an Utopia-Maximizer Look Like?
Thane Ruthenis
2y
9
8Harsanyi's Social Aggregation Theorem and what it means for CEV
AlexMennen
13y
0
13Insufficient Values
Jozdien, Jacob Abraham, Abraham Francis
4y
0
Add Posts