This is a special post for quick takes by leogao. Only they can create top-level comments. Comments here also appear on the Quick Takes page and All Posts page.
i think of the idealized platonic researcher as the person who has chosen ultimate (intellectual) freedom over all else. someone who really cares about some particular thing that nobody else does - maybe because they see the future before anyone else does, or maybe because they just really like understanding everything about ants or abstract mathematical objects or something. in exchange for the ultimate intellectual freedom, they give up vast amounts of money, status, power, etc.
one thing that makes me sad is that modern academia is, as far as I can tell, not this. when you opt out of the game of the Economy, in exchange for giving up real money, status, and power, what you get from Academia is another game of money, status, and power, with different rules, and much lower stakes, and also everyone is more petty about everything.
at the end of the day, what's even the point of all this? to me, it feels like sacrificing everything for nothing if you eschew money, status, and power, and then just write a terrible irreplicable p-hacked paper that reduces the net amount of human knowledge by adding noise and advances your career so you can do more terrible useless papers. at that point, why not just leave academia and go to industry and do something equally useless for human knowledge but get paid stacks of cash for it?
ofc there are people in academia who do good work but it often feels like the incentives force most work to be this kind of horrible slop.
Have you seen A Master-Slave Model of Human Preferences? To summarize, I think every human is trying to optimize for status, consciously or subconsciously, including those who otherwise fit your description of idealized platonic researcher. For example, I'm someone who has (apparently) "chosen ultimate (intellectual) freedom over all else", having done all of my research outside of academia or any formal organizations, but on reflection I think I was striving for status (prestige) as much as anyone, it was just that my subconscious picked a different strat... (read more)