AI ALIGNMENT FORUM
AF

Wikitags

AI Takeoff

Edited by Ruby, Multicore, et al. last updated 30th Dec 2024

AI Takeoff is the process of an Artificial General Intelligence going from a certain threshold of capability (often discussed as "human-level") to being super-intelligent and capable enough to control the fate of civilization. There has been much debate about whether AI takeoff is more likely to be slow vs fast, i.e., "soft" vs "hard".

See also: AI Timelines, Seed AI, Singularity, Intelligence explosion, Recursive self-improvement

AI takeoff is sometimes casually referred to as AI FOOM.

Soft takeoff

A soft takeoff refers to an AGI that would self-improve over a period of years or decades. This could be due to either the learning algorithm being too demanding for the hardware or because the AI relies on experiencing feedback from the real-world that would have to be played out in real-time. Possible methods that could deliver a soft takeoff, by slowly building on human-level intelligence, are Whole brain emulation, Biological Cognitive Enhancement, and software-based strong AGI [1]. By maintaining control of the AGI's ascent it should be easier for a Friendly AI to emerge.

Vernor Vinge, Hans Moravec and have all expressed the view that soft takeoff is preferable to a hard takeoff as it would be both safer and easier to engineer.

Hard takeoff

A hard takeoff (or an AI going "FOOM" [2]) refers to AGI expansion in a matter of minutes, days, or months. It is a fast, abruptly, local increase in capability. This scenario is widely considered much more precarious, as this involves an AGI rapidly ascending in power without human control. This may result in unexpected or undesired behavior (i.e. Unfriendly AI). It is one of the main ideas supporting the Intelligence explosion hypothesis.

The feasibility of hard takeoff has been addressed by Hugo de Garis, Eliezer Yudkowsky, Ben Goertzel, Nick Bostrom, and Michael Anissimov. It is widely agreed that a hard takeoff is something to be avoided due to the risks. Yudkowsky points out several possibilities that would make a hard takeoff more likely than a soft takeoff such as the existence of large resources overhangs or the fact that small improvements seem to have a large impact in a mind's general intelligence (i.e.: the small genetic difference between humans and chimps lead to huge increases in capability) [3].

Notable posts

  • Hard Takeoff by Eliezer Yudkowsky

External links

  • The Age of Virtuous Machines by J. Storrs Hall President of The Foresight Institute
  • Hard take off Hypothesis by Ben Goertzel.
  • Extensive archive of Hard takeoff Essays from Accelerating Future
  • Can we avoid a hard take off? by Vernor Vinge
  • Robot: Mere Machine to Transcendent Mind by Hans Moravec
  • The Singularity is Near by Ray Kurzweil

References

  1. http://www.aleph.se/andart/archives/2010/10/why_early_singularities_are_softer.html↩
  2. http://lesswrong.com/lw/63t/requirements_for_ai_to_go_foom/↩
  3. http://lesswrong.com/lw/wf/hard_takeoff/↩
Subscribe
2
Subscribe
2
Discussion0
Discussion0
Posts tagged AI Takeoff
32Arguments about fast takeoff
paulfchristiano
8y
1
15Will AI undergo discontinuous progress?
Sammy Martin
6y
6
39Soft takeoff can still lead to decisive strategic advantage
Daniel Kokotajlo
6y
34
28Takeoff Speeds and Discontinuities
Sammy Martin, Daniel_Eth
4y
1
53Against GDP as a metric for timelines and takeoff speeds
Daniel Kokotajlo
5y
10
69Yudkowsky and Christiano discuss "Takeoff Speeds"
Eliezer Yudkowsky
4y
97
17Modelling Continuous Progress
Sammy Martin
5y
3
54Conjecture internal survey: AGI timelines and probability of human extinction from advanced AI
Maris Sala
2y
0
30Distinguishing definitions of takeoff
Matthew Barnett
6y
2
40Possible takeaways from the coronavirus pandemic for slow AI takeoff
Vika
5y
27
28My current framework for thinking about AGI timelines
zhukeepa
5y
0
40Review of Soft Takeoff Can Still Lead to DSA
Daniel Kokotajlo
5y
6
29Continuing the takeoffs debate
Richard_Ngo
5y
9
27Analogies and General Priors on Intelligence
riceissa, Sammy Martin
4y
11
55Everything I Need To Know About Takeoff Speeds I Learned From Air Conditioner Ratings On Amazon
johnswentworth
3y
38
Load More (15/72)
Add Posts